E08271: a 'register' statement constructs what it registers - call a constructor of the component or service (and of each aspect), not a function, method or delegate
What went wrong
A 'register' statement must CONSTRUCT what it registers. The application builds each registered value itself, in the order the 'register' statements are written, before any program runs - so the registered expression is a constructor call of the component (with 'as') or the service (without 'as'). The same holds for each aspect in 'with aspect of'.
These are rejected: the result of a function ('register makeOther() as Other'), a call through a function delegate, a service made by a function, a dynamic function, and an aspect made by a function ('with aspect of makeTracing()').
A factory can reach an injection that is not registered yet, and whatever it returned would be stored as the component - the application could not check its wiring.
Worked examples
Compilable examples demonstrating this error and the correct fix:
- ek9 -q 326 (What is the EK9 equivalent of Spring @Bean and @Configuration?)
- ek9 -q 228 (Why does registration order matter in EK9 applications?)
The [EXAMPLE] section below shows a component registered from a factory function, then the factory's work moved into the component's constructor (which injects what it needs) and the component registered by a constructor call, after what it injects.
How to fix it
- Register a constructor call: 'register Impl() as AbstractType', or 'register SomeService()'.
- Move the factory's work into the component's constructor; anything it needs is injected there, and must be registered before it (E08200).
- For an aspect, construct it: 'with aspect of Tracing()', where Tracing extends Aspect.
Common causes
- Spring @Bean / Guice @Provides habit: a factory method that builds the component
- Wanting to choose an implementation at runtime - define a separate application per configuration
- Passing a delegate variable that holds a factory function
See also
- E08271: a registration that is not a constructor call (this error)
- E50020: the constructed type is not a component (with 'as') or not a service (without 'as')
- E50030: the constructed component is not the 'as' type, or an aspect is not an Aspect
- E08200: a registration injects something registered after it
- E08210: an injection reachable from a program is not registered
Examples
Every example is compiled by the EK9 compiler: the first fails exactly as captioned, the others fix it.
Fails with E08271: a 'register' statement constructs what it registers - call a constructor of the component or service (and of each aspect), not a function, method or delegate
#!ek9 defines module error.e08271.bad defines function makeOther() <- rtn as Other: Labelled() defines component Svc as abstract name() as abstract <- rtn as String? SvcImpl is Svc override name() <- rtn as String: "service" Other as abstract tag() as abstract <- rtn as String? Labelled is Other label as String? Labelled() svc as Svc! label: svc.name() override tag() <- rtn as String: label default operator ? defines application App register SvcImpl() as Svc register makeOther() as Other
Fixed: Register a constructor call of the component
#!ek9 defines module error.e08271.good defines component Svc as abstract name() as abstract <- rtn as String? SvcImpl is Svc override name() <- rtn as String: "service" Other as abstract tag() as abstract <- rtn as String? Labelled is Other label as String? Labelled() svc as Svc! label: svc.name() override tag() <- rtn as String: label default operator ? defines application App register SvcImpl() as Svc register Labelled() as Other
Found a problem?
If EK9 reported E08271 for a program you think is valid, or did not report it where it should have, use the compiler form with the smallest program that shows it. If this page is wrong or unclear, use the documentation form. Both are at github.com/ek9lang/ek9-issues.