E01072: 'return' does not exist in EK9 - declare return values with '<-' and compiler ensures all paths initialize
What went wrong
The 'return' statement does not exist in EK9.
Worked examples
Compilable examples demonstrating this error and the correct fix:
Rationale
EK9 excludes early returns based on critical security evidence:
- Apple SSL Bug (2014, CVE-2014-1266): Duplicate 'goto fail' bypassed SSL validation
- An early exit between acquiring a resource and releasing it skips the release
- Multiple return points make code harder to reason about
How to fix it
Declare return variable with '<-' and let compiler enforce all paths initialize it. Use guards for conditional processing.
See also
- E01070: 'break' not supported (use stream pipelines with 'head')
- E01071: 'continue' not supported (use stream pipelines with 'filter')
- E01072: 'return' not supported (use return declarations)
- E01073: 'null' not supported (use tri-state semantics)
- E01074: semicolons not needed (indentation-based syntax)
https://ek9.io/flowControl.html#guard_decision_tree https://ek9.io/forAI.json#$.excludedFeatures.features[?(@.keyword=="return")]
Examples
Every example is compiled by the EK9 compiler: the first fails exactly as captioned, the others fix it.
Fails with E01072: 'return' does not exist in EK9 - declare return values with '<-' and compiler ensures all paths initialize
#!ek9 defines module error.e01072.bad defines constant LIMIT <- 100 defines function //Return with a value tryReturnWithValue() -> text as String <- result as String: String() return text //Return without a value (void return) tryReturnWithoutValue() -> message as String if message? Stdout().println(message) return //Early return in conditional tryEarlyReturn() -> name as String <- result as String: String() if not name? return "anonymous" //Return inside a for loop tryReturnInForLoop() -> items as List of Integer <- result as Integer: Integer() for item in items if item > LIMIT return item //Return inside a while loop tryReturnInWhileLoop() -> items as List of Integer <- result as Integer: Integer() iter <- items.iterator() while iter.hasNext() item <- iter.next() if item > LIMIT return item
Fixed: Assign the returning variable where each return was
#!ek9 defines module error.e01072.good.fix defines constant LIMIT <- 100 defines function //Return with a value tryReturnWithValue() -> text as String <- result as String: String() result: text //Return without a value (void return) tryReturnWithoutValue() -> message as String if message? Stdout().println(message) //Early return in conditional tryEarlyReturn() -> name as String <- result as String: String() if not name? result: "anonymous" //Return inside a for loop tryReturnInForLoop() -> items as List of Integer <- result as Integer: Integer() for item in items if item > LIMIT result :=? item //Return inside a while loop tryReturnInWhileLoop() -> items as List of Integer <- result as Integer: Integer() iter <- items.iterator() while iter.hasNext() item <- iter.next() if item > LIMIT result :=? item
Fixed: Declare the returning variable and assign it; the compiler checks every path
#!ek9 defines module error.e01072.good defines function describe() -> name as String <- description as String: "anonymous" if name? description: "named " + name firstOver() -> items as List of Integer threshold as Integer <- found as Integer: Integer() for item in items if item > threshold found :=? item
Questions and answers
These Q&A entries show E01072 and its fix:
- Q19: Can I use EK9 for scripting?
- Q49: How do I define a function in EK9?
- Q61: How do if/else statements work in EK9?
- Q62: How do I chain multiple if/else-if conditions?
- Q63: How does switch/case work in EK9?
- Q68: Can switch return a value (switch as expression)?
- Q71: How do pattern matching and regex work in switch?
- Q72: What are given/when — alternative switch keywords?
- Q73: How does exhaustive enum switch work?
- Q74: How do guard variables work in if statements?
- Q75: How do guard variables work in switch statements?
- Q76: How do guard variables work in for loops?
- Q78: How do guard variables work in try blocks?
- Q80: Can a for-range loop return a value (for-range as expression)?
- Q81: Can while and do-while loops return values (loop expressions)?
- Q82: Can a for-in loop return a value (for-in as expression)?
- Q83: Which control flow constructs can be used as expressions in EK9?
- Q144: Why doesn't EK9 have break, continue, or return statements?
- Q145: How do I exit a loop early or skip iterations in EK9?
- Q146: How do I structure functions without early return in EK9?
- Q147: Why doesn't EK9 have switch fallthrough and how do I group cases?
- Q148: How do I migrate complex control flow from Java or Python to EK9?
- Q274: Why does AI generate return statements in EK9?
- Q597: How do function parameters work in EK9?
- Q748: How do I migrate Swift control flow patterns to EK9?
- Q997: How do I write a function that returns a value in EK9?
- Q998: Show me different function signatures in EK9 — no params, one param, multiple params, with return.
- Q999: Write an EK9 function that takes a list of integers and returns the sum of all positive values.
- Q1006: I'm a Python developer. What are the key differences I need to know for EK9?
- Q1025: How do := and :=? work differently as guard operators in EK9 control flow?
- Q1032: My function uses return to send back a value. How do I fix it?
- Q1153: Assign different labels based on a score using if/else.
- Q1168: Write a pure validation function that checks if an age is between 0 and 150.
- Q1196: How do I guard a date lookup so the block only runs if a date is found?
- Q1267: How do I find the first matching item in a list without break or return in EK9?
Found a problem?
If EK9 reported E01072 for a program you think is valid, or did not report it where it should have, use the compiler form with the smallest program that shows it. If this page is wrong or unclear, use the documentation form. Both are at github.com/ek9lang/ek9-issues.